Europe

Germany grants BND and BfV broad surveillance and covert action powers

Published

on

As part of the rebuilding of German militarism, the Bundestag on Friday approved a comprehensive reform of legislation governing intelligence agencies in the form of an “Enabling Act”.

In the vote, 309 lawmakers voted in favour, 190 voted against and 71 abstained. The abstentions came from the Greens parliamentary group.

The law grants the Federal Intelligence Service (BND) and the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV) powers euphemistically termed “active measures”, which lawyer Rolf Gössner has described as “theft and sabotage”.

According to junge Welt (jW), fundamental rights and the Basic Law are being left at the mercy of the arbitrary power of the intelligence agencies.

The alleged “hybrid” warfare threat facing the Federal Republic is cited as justification for the measure.

Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt (CSU) spoke of a “reform of the century” and welcomed the fact that Germany now has “real intelligence agencies”.

According to the governing parties, these agencies had until now done nothing more than gather intelligence.

In any event, the BfV will in future be able to enter homes and access computers without a court order, use minors as informants and establish a comprehensive artificial intelligence-based surveillance system.

In other words, it will be able to continue doing legally what it has hitherto done without a legal basis.

Similarly, the BND will be permitted to disable servers abroad, reroute data traffic, delete data and spread disinformation.

Even before agreement was reached on the reform plan, the Bundeswehr was conducting electronic warfare exercises against Russia and Belarus in Lithuania at the end of October.

Page 544 of the draft bill, which exceeds 600 pages, also contains a provision that could be interpreted as a “licence to kill”.

This provision states that the BND may carry out “direct action” “using kinetic means”.

At the last minute on Wednesday, the CDU/CSU and SPD added a clause to the bill allowing the BfV to restrict cooperation with state administrations.

This step was taken following election victories by the AfD in Saxony-Anhalt and the Left Party in Berlin.

The newly coined term “special state of determination”, which appears repeatedly in the bill, is being described as a “legal oddity”. The concept is added alongside the existing “state of defence” and “state of tension”, but with a key difference: while kept secret even from the Bundestag, it significantly expands the powers of the entire security apparatus without any time limit.

In practice, decisions on this matter rest with the agency heads. Put more plainly, the intelligence services are assuming the authority to suspend the constitution and the laws themselves.

During the plenary debate, Left Party lawmaker Clara Bünger rightly stated that this would create an “uncontrollable apparatus that tramples on fundamental rights” and a “new German secret police”.

According to Bünger, Dobrindt is handing these powers over to the AfD “ready for use”.

The Left Party and the AfD voted against the bill.

During the debate, AfD lawmaker Gottfried Curio accused the coalition of creating a “snooping state” (Spitzelstaat) and abolishing the separation between the police and intelligence services.

The party argued that expanding the powers of the domestic intelligence agency (BfV), such as covertly entering homes, infiltrating devices and recruiting informants from parliamentary staff, violates fundamental rights and directly threatens the political opposition.

While voting against the government’s reform, the AfD submitted its own separate motion aimed specifically at strengthening the operational capacity of the foreign intelligence service (BND), though that motion was rejected by all other parliamentary groups.

On Thursday, 28 civil rights organizations, including the Humanist Union, the Committee for Fundamental Rights and Democracy, the Republican Lawyers’ Association (RAV) and Rote Hilfe, had written an open letter to Bundestag members urging them to vote against the bill.

The signatories assessed the draft legislation as “a threat to democracy, largely unconstitutional and irresponsible” and a “shift toward a surveillance state”, arguing that such a state is needed by “those preparing for war”.

MOST READ

Exit mobile version