Opinion
Notes from Germany: Lux in Tenebris
Scene one: In one of Berlin’s polite neighbourhoods, three or four people with Ukrainian flags stand in front of the Russian House, whose lease has been cancelled. Similar figures can also be seen on the street outside the Russian Embassy, which is protected by iron railings. It is hardly a crowd to be taken seriously, yet its impact on German politics must be taken very seriously indeed. Whether you see clouds in the air or not, the sky is murky and the needle is swinging towards cold. Nobody pays any attention to the small group with Ukrainian flags; the German government, however, mistakes that indifference for a green light for war.
Scene two: Looking from cosmopolitan and chaotic Berlin to small but stark Magdeburg, things change. Beyond mere metaphor, there is a real scene before us: there, members of the AfD and the BSW are beaming at one another. Election results in the state of which the city is the capital are forcing “unity”. It is as if this were the address of hope against war, though not every war: the establishment of a weapons factory in the state by an Israeli company causes stomach ache among AfD members, yet they barely bat an eyelid. A few dozen people, whose numbers rarely change, never fail to applaud generously. The German mainstream media is also attentive; AfD members take care not to slip up.
Scene three: We are back in Berlin. The first taxi driver, as we usually encounter, is Turkish. He says he voted for “Elif”. Is there much talk that she will fail? He says he will withdraw his support. The magic word is “integration”; yet he is angry with the Germans, and the sense of being downtrodden persists. The driver changes, but the theme remains the same: a Yemeni migrant, in his broken German and English, immediately objects upon hearing “the Houthis” and starts listing: Umar ibn al-Khattab, Abu Bakr… Stirred-up regional tensions and the personal backgrounds of migrants are reproduced inside Germany. This pool holds not only dangers for the German state, but opportunities as well. Anyone who wishes can look at the “new Syria”, or at the Turk appointed to head domestic intelligence.
What is the AfD’s crime?
Thinking about what we saw and heard in Berlin and Magdeburg, one is forced to pause and wonder why, aside from “one or two minor things”, the AfD is at odds with the “establishment” at all.
Of course, it is no small matter: the Ukraine crisis and the possibility of a general European war keep Germany on edge. Although the migration issue has lost its former urgency, it still occupies a prominent place in all speeches by AfD members. On these two critical headings, the AfD remains, in part, the black sheep.
I say in part, because there are obvious signs of softening. Ask anyone in the AfD, and almost all agree that there is more than one AfD: there is a “West German” AfD that adopts a pro-NATO, pro-armament, and pro-war stance; and there is an East German AfD that submits a joint peace motion with the BSW. Indeed, according to some, there is also Björn Höcke’s ethno-nationalist (völkisch) AfD. Even the issue of “remigration” has become “nuanced” for a party that wants at least to strike a chord with German big capital: no more new migration, yes, but where should the line be drawn for older migrants? Many regard those who arrived after the 2015 crisis as “illegal”; yet some local AfD politicians are actively campaigning to win the votes of Turks, believing that Turks, just like themselves, are socially conservative. One reveals his enthusiasm by saying, “We want nothing to do with Shariaists, but there are even Turks who eat pork!” Another admits that the question of who will wash the dishes once the migrants leave is the elephant in the room.
Whichever way one looks at it, it is clear that the party in the West, at least, is CDU 2.0 (liberal, market-oriented, conservative), while the party in the East is more “social”. On peace with Russia, for instance, the Saxony-Anhalt branch appears to speak unequivocally. A similar attitude holds for the Russian-speaking German-Russian community in Berlin and, more broadly, in the state of Brandenburg. If we count everyone from the Russians who fled to Germany after the October Revolution, to those who arrived with the Red Army, Soviet citizens who settled in East Berlin, and ethnic Germans who came from the USSR after the counter-revolution, we arrive at a population of nearly 35,000. Local AfD politicians do not seem to look unkindly upon this community either.
Indeed, the AfD’s lack of hostility towards Russia and Russians is cited as proof that it is not fascist. After all, in the 20th century, the nemesis of German imperialism, and of Nazism which inherited its worst traits, was Russia. While one reason for the Nazi invasion of the USSR was a holy war against Bolshevism, another was the cleansing of its own east, its “living space”, of inferior Slavs.
Fine, then, but today, as German imperialism once again sets its sights eastward, if one leg of the stool is hostility towards Russia, the others are Germany’s rearmament, NATO, and relations with the US.
The AfD’s stance on Germany’s rearmament can, at best, be described as “kicking the ball around”. For example, AfD members in Magdeburg say “800 billion euros for rearmament is too much” (how much, for instance, would not be too much?), and are then forced to openly admit that there is no consensus within the party on this issue. A local politician in Berlin voices the fantasy, “Let’s have 20 nuclear bombs and no army”, but adds: “I am in a minority in the party!” In fact, Siegmund Ulrich, the lead candidate in Saxony-Anhalt, had already blurted out that alongside rearmament, they could use the army to chase away migrants.
Conscription and the improvement of the Bundeswehr’s domestic logistics and infrastructure are also among the policies the AfD advocates. Whenever armament, the militarization of culture, and the strengthening of the army are on the agenda, AfD members join the bandwagon, saying “we are a right-wing party”. The same softening trend is observed regarding the US and NATO. The term “transatlantic right”, popularized by the BSW’s Sevim Dağdelen in a recent article, appears to have been adopted even by some AfD members. The fact that senior AfD figures like Beatrix von Storch have become regulars in Washington, Elon Musk’s attendance at AfD congresses, and the shadow of JD Vance and his patron Peter Thiel over German-Austrian politics complicate the matter further. The Trump administration’s push to bring Germany forward while reducing its NATO commitments in Europe seems to have sparked a modest excitement among AfD members. Their outlook on the EU and NATO is being recalibrated, adapted to this new situation.
Add to this Israel, the untouchable of the “establishment”. For the most “advanced” AfD member, “Jews” and “Muslims” are equally guilty. Even stranger, however, is what was said immediately after the Saxony-Anhalt elections in the debate over the Elbit Systems factory, sparked once again by Ulrich firing the signal flare: the AfD lead candidate stated that they would not oppose factories built for “ammunition production” and tied the now-familiar “remigration” issue to the debate surrounding this Israeli arms company. Although AfD members in Magdeburg express doubts about the Elbit Systems factory, they have found a baffling side road: let us put whether to build the (Israeli) weapons factory to a referendum and ask the people! If the people say yes, they will not object to the weapons factory being built. The AfD member who is “personally opposed” to Elbit building a factory again admits that there is no unity within the party on this matter. Clearly, for a local AfD politician, the way out of an issue that is unpopular, especially in East Germany, lies through the arguments that “there is no unity in the party on that issue” yet “he himself is personally opposed”.
The Israeli influence is embodied in Maximilian Krah, once one of the party’s most prominent faces: sidelined after an aide working for him in the Bundestag was accused of being a “Chinese spy” and after he remarked that “not everyone who wore an SS uniform was automatically a criminal”, this AfD figure somehow suddenly became enamoured of Israel and rushed off to Tel Aviv. He guaranteed that they would continue to bear Germany’s responsibility for the Holocaust, tried to convince Israelis that antisemitism in Europe today comes not from the right but from the left, and added that he was certain the ice between the AfD and Israel would melt.
Speaking of Israel… The Freedom Party of Austria (FPÖ), which the AfD regards as a sister party and whose Saxony-Anhalt team visited it to benefit from its experience in government, along with its leader Herbert Kickl, are also among those recently dazzled by the Israeli sun. The Likudization of the European right does not sink in Lake Constance; it marches on.¹
Indeed, this issue of “buyability”, in both senses of the word, is throwing the AfD off balance. An AfD politician explaining his views on Berlin’s housing problem opposes the Left Party’s expropriation proposal with CDU-like ferocity, while listing as his solution the deportation of Ukrainian refugees and, nevertheless, the construction of new housing. Who, then, will build the new housing? The city of Berlin is in debt, and the AfD opposes new debt; it also opposes private investors building it. So what will happen? Cooperation with the CDU in Berlin’s neighbourhoods will presumably bear fruit here in the form of more market and deregulation.
BSW: Over, over, not over
The same indecisiveness exists in the BSW. Of course, the BSW’s situation cannot even be compared to that of the AfD: having barely scraped into parliament in Saxony-Anhalt, falling below the threshold in Berlin and Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, criticized for governing with the old/established parties in Brandenburg and Thuringia, and fracturing from within, the party is fighting a battle for survival.
Precisely for this reason, they see flirting with the AfD in Saxony-Anhalt as a kind of leverage. At least the state branch and certain intermediaries are pushing for this. While their similar stances on the Ukraine issue take concrete form in a joint motion, cooperation in the state could, for some, become a model at the federal level as well. The BSW’s lead candidate in Saxony-Anhalt, Claudia Wittig, plays to this with her constant smiling and nodding at AfD members. So do the anti-Americanism and the emphasis on German culture and what is German.
But which German? At the event in Magdeburg, an artist who appears to be close to the left quotes Brecht. Another prominent figure speaks of the German Hegel, of Aufheben, which we might translate as transcending by preserving, elevating by both retaining and negating its content, and of the unbreakable ties between patriotism and internationalism. He mediates with the AfD on behalf of migrants who speak German, pay their taxes in Germany, and obey German laws, pleading with them not to frighten these people by talking of remigration. The AfD member, meanwhile, says the left-right distinction means nothing; another likens Germany to “North Korea”. For whatever reason, while leftists deem it unnecessary to emphasize the left, right-wingers wink at a kind of right-wing international.
In the BSW, everyone is at odds with everyone else; nobody likes anybody. It is impossible to hear anything positive about co-chairs Amira Mohamed Ali or Fabio De Masi, even from people close to the BSW. Some are angry with Sahra Wagenknecht; others think Wittig is inadequate.
In fact, the experiment in Saxony-Anhalt oscillates on a scale between biting off more than one can chew and pure fantasy. Indeed, the party leadership has launched belated salvos against the possibility of being politically (and perhaps even organizationally) swallowed by the AfD. Leaders, led by Sevim Dağdelen, are trying to clarify their position by pointing to the AfD’s ethno-nationalist and transatlantic-right ties, as well as its stance against the welfare state.
But is it enough? Does viewing the AfD simply as a “political rival” allow one to understand this party’s specific historical role? Moreover, could the connection pulling the AfD towards the “establishment”, namely Israel, also be quietly and deeply reaching into the BSW? A journalist well-informed about the BSW reports, for instance, that certain shady characters hovering around the party are making moves to push steadfast anti-Israel figures like Sevim Dağdelen out of the organization by branding them “pro-Hamas”. Some declare the party finished, some think it will know how to rise just as it sank, and some even think the “left” of the Left Party and the “left” of the BSW could break away from their parties and form a new movement…
The (gloomy) sky over Berlin
To kill time, I step into a bookshop. Again to pass the time, I buy a book that catches my eye and begin reading. Its title is Beyond the Wall, by Katja Hoyer. No English-language book has ever told the history of the German Democratic Republic so vividly, someone says in the blurbs on the first page.
The colour palette is as follows: devout German communists rotting in Stalin’s prisons and Gulags; drunken Red Army soldiers on occupied Prussian soil, emboldened by their daily vodka rations, organizing mass rape sessions; the Ulbricht group, yes-men to Stalin and to the Red Army headquarters, the occupation authority in East Germany… and so it goes on. According to the author, Stalin, who met personally with the German delegation 11 times between 1945 and 1952, could not possibly have held these meetings out of any genuine interest in Germany’s political future; this was merely a sign of his distrust of his German comrades!
A complete waste of time. Yet it says something about the German intelligentsia and political class. This colourful history is, in reality, a bleak and putrid narrative of pessimism. In this history, there are no people rolling up their sleeves to leave the devastation of war behind and build a new country. It is a brand of nihilism incapable of understanding why the national anthem of the German Democratic Republic, beginning with “Auferstanden aus Ruinen” (Risen from Ruins), is still sung with longing today in the eastern German states, even by AfD members. One AfD adviser admits that Alice Weidel might say one thing today and something 180 degrees opposite next week. Indifference to Germany’s future has engulfed everything, even, in this context, the AfD.
On the other hand, the nihilism of the intelligentsia appears destined to lose against the hope pumped out by the AfD. The Germans call it Irrlicht; in folktales, a supernatural, even demonic quality is attributed to the false light that appears in marshes. The political nihilism into which Germany has sunk is elevating the AfD, which also feeds on nostalgia for East Germany.
Looking at the false light spread by the AfD, Brecht comes to mind once again. In one of his early plays, combining a critique of bourgeois morality with the biblical metaphor of “Light in Darkness” (Lux in Tenebris), Brecht left his protagonist, the bigoted Paul, standing outside a “brothel” in his neighbourhood to shelter from a storm. This polite gentleman, who had dedicated his life to fighting decay and darkness, suddenly found himself illuminated by the neon lights of the brothel right next to his own world, which he had thought so solid. And inspired by The Threepenny Opera, one might also think that to see the truth, one must look not at those in the light, but at those in the dark. As dark clouds gather once more in the German sky, thinking that optimism might be connected to our eyes adjusting to the dark could set our minds free.
¹ On this side of the lake, journalist Hüseyin Doğru is subjected to EU sanctions on the grounds of supporting the Palestinian resistance. Do not dismiss it as mere sanctions: Doğru cannot even use a credit card, his bank accounts are closed, he cannot pay his bills, and it is even uncertain whether he could return if he left the country. EU legislation practically buries sanctioned individuals alive.