America
US general forced to resign could face trial over leak allegations
The administration of US President Donald Trump has ordered a review into whether to launch a military criminal investigation against Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia, who was forced to step down over allegations that he leaked classified information to the press.
Files concerning Sylvia, whom Pentagon leadership accuses of passing classified data to journalists, had also previously been referred to the US Department of Justice.
Speaking on condition of anonymity, a US official confirmed to The Washington Post (WP) that the file has been forwarded to Acting Secretary of the Army Adam Tell for “appropriate disposition”.
The newspaper reported that Sylvia now faces the risk of prosecution through both military and civilian judicial channels.
Military authorities and federal law enforcement have not yet brought formal charges against the general.
Sylvia, 54, has made no public comment on the matter.
Removed from his post at the end of October, Sylvia headed the strategy, plans and policy directorate on the Joint Staff, reporting to Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Dan Caine.
Sylvia previously commanded the 101st Airborne Division.
Pentagon makes accusations, sources offer conflicting accounts
When news broke on 29 October that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s team had forced the general to resign, Pentagon Spokesperson Sean Parnell wrote on social media: “We meant what we said. We promised to find you and we weren’t joking.”
Parnell alleged that the officer had put US troops at risk by deliberately disclosing classified information.
WP noted that officials have not publicly disclosed the exact allegations against Sylvia.
Following Sylvia’s dismissal, reporters at conservative media outlets published a statement attributed to an unnamed department representative.
The statement alleged that Sylvia had leaked classified information regarding the war with Iran, the Russia-Ukraine war and other matters.
The same statement claimed that the general met reporters outside the department building to circumvent press restrictions and failed a polygraph test three times.
The official who confirmed the transfer of the file to the newspaper claimed that Sylvia had admitted to investigators that he took notes from classified documents, passed that information to a journalist and deleted messages on the Signal application.
The news website Axios also reported on 29 October, citing an internal report, that the general had admitted to leaking information to reporters from two news organizations.
According to other WP sources, however, Sylvia told colleagues that he had spoken with reporters but had not shared classified information.
The newspaper emphasized that it could not independently verify these claims and that the Pentagon refused to provide a copy of its internal investigation report.
Lawyers say securing a conviction would be difficult
WP noted that the investigation into the general forms part of the Trump administration’s campaign against information leaks.
Hegseth had pledged to track down and punish those who spoke to the press about Pentagon operations, particularly during the war with Iran.
The department has made widespread use of polygraph tests and non-disclosure agreements for this purpose.
The Department of Justice did not confirm whether an investigation into Sylvia is underway, stating only that it is interested in potential leaks of classified information.
A previous attempt by Hegseth’s team to punish suspected sources through federal agencies ended without result.
Sources speaking to WP said securing a conviction in the case would not be easy.
For example, it remains unclear whether the general generalized the information to avoid disclosing classified data, as senior officers frequently do during press briefings.
Nor is the deletion of messages alone considered proof of a crime.
Military justice experts note that in an environment where Hegseth’s team is openly demanding punishment, the military justice system must remain free from pressure by senior officials.
Experts argue the legal process itself has become the punishment
According to retired Army officer and lawyer Franklin Rosenblatt, the aim of the case may be to send a message rather than to secure the general’s conviction.
Rosenblatt said: “In many recent national security scandals in the second Trump administration, the process itself becomes the punishment. Those in power open investigations without realistically assessing whether they can take cases to court or obtain a conviction.”
Rosenblatt said the general’s defense team would almost certainly raise the issue of unlawful command influence, which is described as “the mortal enemy of military justice”.
Yale Law School faculty member Eugene Fidell said that if the case goes to a court-martial, Sylvia’s fate would likely be decided by a jury of eight generals superior to him in rank or seniority.
Rosenblatt added that alongside leaking classified information, the general could also face charges of disobedience of orders, conduct unbecoming an officer and contempt toward senior civilian officials.
The lawyer said he found reliance on polygraph tests “problematic”, noting that courts do not accept such test results as evidence and that the Pentagon’s public statements on the matter could influence prospective jurors.
“Machines should not decide who is credible and who is lying; a jury should,” the expert said.