Diplomacy
Anti-war sentiment is growing stronger in our country, American journalist Andrew Day says
Editor’s note: Speaking at the East-West Forum held in Istanbul on September 26, Andrew Day, senior editor at The American Conservative, assessed regional proxy wars through the lens of US domestic politics and foreign policy perspective. Recalling The American Conservative’s founding anti-war stance, Day stated that opposition to foreign interventions is now gaining stronger traction within conservative circles, noting that American public opinion is shifting rapidly, particularly regarding US-Israel relations and the War with Iran. Day characterized the war against Iran as an unnecessary war of aggression, stating that it has accelerated the relative decline of the US, the depletion of weapons stockpiles, and the unraveling of the liberal order.
Hello, everyone.
I see that we are supposed to be talking about regional proxy wars. Since my country, the United States, seems to be responsible in large part for all of those wars, I will offer some comments on the domestic political situation in the United States, which I hope will shed light on the geopolitical situation.
That geopolitical situation is obviously very grim, perhaps even grimmer than the organizers expected when they first planned this conference. Nevertheless, I will try to identify some grounds for optimism. That can be a rather lame thing to do, but I am not going to invent these grounds for optimism. I think they are real.
You can see on the screen behind me that I am a senior editor at the American Conservative. If you are unfamiliar with the magazine, you might be surprised to learn that it was founded in 2002 in opposition to the Iraq War.
Obviously, the Iraq War had not yet begun when the magazine was founded in 2002, but we knew it was coming. Our co-founders, most prominently Pat Buchanan, wanted a magazine on the right that was antiwar and fiercely opposed to the coming war in Iraq.
As for grounds for optimism, one thing I will say is that, as much as I might like to puff myself up, it requires very little courage these days to be a conservative campaigning against war. It is nothing like 2002, when Pat Buchanan started the American Conservative.
He was subjected to a deluge of attacks on his character. He was marginalized and maligned as an antisemite. Of course, people still say nasty things online, but it is very different now. It is easier to get the word out, and you are more readily accepted as a member of the conservative movement and as representing a right-wing tendency that is genuinely strong in the United States: scepticism of these foreign wars and fierce opposition to them.
I think that is a genuine source of optimism. It points to an important fact: American public opinion has changed enormously on various issues, including the US-Israel relationship. This is a real development, and it is happening at an incredible rate.
Nevertheless, the story within the political establishment is different, and it is quite disappointing. No matter what politicians say on the campaign trail, it seems that between their election victory and their inauguration, they must attend some secret national security establishment university.
Anatol Lieven used a phrase earlier. What was it? “Weird world of illusions.” I think that might be the curriculum at this national security establishment university that all these politicians attend. By the time they are in office, they are all spouting the same clichés, which have no evident correspondence to today’s geopolitical situation.
As for the craziness they spout, China hawkishness is quite crazy. Russia hawkishness is quite crazy. But clearly the craziest form of hawkishness in America is Iran hawkishness.
Iran is a middle power on the other side of the world, not a peer competitor and not a nuclear state. It was not only willing to reach a nuclear deal with the United States; it actually signed one. According to Trump’s own administration during his first term, Iran was complying with the nuclear deal it had signed.
Nevertheless, we withdrew from it. We all know what happened next.
I think the Iran War is an accelerator. At the beginning of the Covid pandemic, a journalist asked the French novelist Michel Houellebecq: “What do you think the social transformation brought about by Covid will be? What do you expect things to look like at the end of this?”
He said: “There won’t be a transformation. It will be the same, but worse.”
I think the Iran War similarly intensifies certain pre-existing tendencies: the decline of the United States relative to China, the depletion of our weapons stockpiles, which was already happening because of the Ukraine War, and the collapse of the liberal order. That includes the good parts of the liberal international order, such as international shipping.
But I do not know whether things will necessarily just be worse. I do not want to look for silver linings in the Iran War because I regard the US war on Iran as a war of aggression: totally unnecessary and totally stupid. It is bad for America and, of course, bad for the Iranian people. On the first day of strikes, we killed 160 schoolgirls. I am not going to look for silver linings there.
I will say, however, that on the other side of this war, the political establishment in the United States might finally recognize that the margin for error is not what it used to be. It is much narrower. The blowback is much greater, and it now comes back to us and hurts politicians politically.
It really must be stressed that this war is very unpopular in the United States. That is not just because of petrol prices. It was unpopular from day one, when all we knew was that Khamenei and the Iranian leaders had been killed. Pete Hegseth could say, “We have won this great, great victory in Iran.” The American people were not buying it.
This is the most unpopular war in American history. That is an enormous change from the Bush administration, as I indicated earlier. The Iraq War was very popular when it began. The Iran War, not so much. I think that reflects some important trends worth highlighting.
I also think that China’s rise could have considerable geopolitical benefits, including for the United States.
I agree that the Cold War now emerging seems, in some ways, worse than the first Cold War. One reason is that our political leadership in the United States is so unfocused and unstrategic.
Regardless of what you think about Zbigniew Brzezinski or Henry Kissinger, and you may hate them for various reasons, they were intellectual giants compared with the intellectual pygmies who now run the State Department.
Compare Brzezinski with Blinken. Brzezinski was plausibly a genius. Blinken barely seems to have any consciousness behind his eyes. He can speak only in platitudes.
I think you can make a similar comparison between Kissinger and certain conservative secretaries of state, one of whom might be in office right now.
This degeneration of America’s strategic acumen is deeply troubling. It is very concerning, and somewhat mysterious, to the foreign policy thinkers in my network in the United States.
There are capable people whom Trump could put on professional diplomatic teams to talk to Tehran, Moscow, and Beijing. He does not have to send his golfing buddy, Steve Witkoff, to all these places.
Nevertheless, he does, and that is concerning. But China’s rise may focus the mind, as happened during the Cold War. Perhaps, in the best case, our strategic thinking will return to something approaching normality, if not brilliance.
Thank you.
Diplomacy
Colby exits Brussels Ukraine talks before defence minister speaks
Elbridge Colby, the US deputy undersecretary of defence for policy, left the Ukraine Defence Contact Group (Ramstein format) talks held in Brussels on Tuesday, 17 November, before Ukrainian Defence Minister Yevhen Hmara began his address.
According to a report by the British newspaper The Telegraph, Colby, who authored the current US National Defence Strategy, opposed the tactic of launching strikes deep inside Russia during the talks.
Colby exited the room ahead of the speech by Ukrainian Defence Minister Hmara, who was presenting a report to his counterparts in a closed session. The US side officially explained his departure by citing the need to catch a flight.
Matthew Whitaker, the US permanent representative to NATO, remained at the meeting to represent the country.
German government sources speaking to The Telegraph said they were “concerned” by the statements of the US official, who criticized Ukraine’s deep strikes into Russian territory.
According to the German sources, Colby described the tactic as having “low military value” and as a method that did not “bring the conflict closer” to an end.
Interlocutors speaking to the newspaper expressed concern over the possibility that, following this development, the Donald Trump administration could “take Russia’s side”.
A source who briefed the British newspaper said:
“During the public portion of the Ramstein meeting, Colby said that the US opposed strikes deep into Russian territory and saw no military benefit in them. Most attendees were shocked by these comments.”
Who is Elbridge Colby?
Colby, a Republican politician, has served as deputy undersecretary of defence for policy at the Pentagon since April 2025 and held a similar role during Trump’s first presidential term.
Colby worked at the US Department of State and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence early in his career, and is the grandson of William Colby, who directed the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) in the 1970s.
The National Defence Strategy released by the Pentagon in January this year, with the 46-year-old Colby as lead author, defined Russia as a “manageable threat”, while projecting that the country maintained “large reserves of military and industrial power” and demonstrated “national resolve”.
The authors of this US strategy placed the responsibility for defending Ukraine and Europe on European partners.
Colby, who identifies the containment of China among the Pentagon’s primary priorities, has long been known to prioritize US competition with that country over the Ukraine and Middle East theatres.
Speaking in March at congressional hearings on the new strategy, Colby argued that the document responded to the principles of “flexible realism”.
The US official said during that hearing:
“This is an attempt to advance and protect the concrete interests of ordinary Americans in a practical and realistic way. At the heart of this strategy, as the document clearly states, lies ‘evaluation, screening and prioritization’.”
Diplomacy
US approved exports of 800,000 Nvidia and AMD chips to China
The US government has approved requests by Nvidia and AMD to ship advanced artificial intelligence chips to certain Chinese companies.
According to the Financial Times (FT), these companies include entities that the Pentagon believes are linked to China’s People’s Liberation Army.
Previously classified records published on Thursday by the Republican-majority House Foreign Affairs Committee show that American companies sought permission to ship more than 3.4 million chips to Chinese firms such as Alibaba, Tencent, Baidu, and BYD over a six-month period beginning in December.
The Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) approved the “export, re-export, or transfer” of 879,868 chips.
During a hearing held to approve the release of the documents, the Republican committee chairman, Brian Mast, said that in Nvidia’s licence applications, “two of the companies listed as being able to install chips in data centres in China are, as far as we know, shell companies.” He added, “Both are fake companies [and] BIS approved the sale of these chips to these firms.”
The disclosure of the documents came as members of Congress pushed for tighter export controls following Jensen Huang’s resignation as Nvidia CEO.
Huang had been in a relationship with Alice Huang, a Singapore-based executive whom American officials determined to be a Chinese spy.
US officials also believe that Alice Huang may have been involved in export control violations by transferring Nvidia’s processors to China.
The Department of Commerce, which houses the BIS, has faced criticism from both Republicans and Democrats over its stance on Nvidia’s sales of advanced AI chips to China.
Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has agreed to testify before the Senate Banking Committee, while Huang is expected to be questioned behind closed doors in Congress next month.
Nvidia did not respond to requests for comment. AMD stated that it “complies with applicable US export control laws and regulations and implements rigorous processes to ensure that compliance across its global operations.”
AMD, which dominates the AI chip market alongside Nvidia, has also come under pressure over its ties to China.
On Thursday, its shares fell %7.7 after two reports linked to short seller Hunterbrook warned of risks stemming from the company’s connections to Beijing and “round-tripping”.
In Washington, Gregory Meeks, the ranking Democrat on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, stated that he voted in favour of releasing the files that revealed the approvals granted to Nvidia and AMD, saying that “over the past month, the administration’s handling of chip export controls has put our national security and technological edge at risk.”
Meeks added, “The public has a right to know how these decisions were made, and releasing this information ensures everyone is reviewing the same set of facts.”
In a separate development on Thursday, the California attorney general sent a subpoena to Nvidia seeking information on “whether its advanced chips or confidential information went to China and whether Nvidia misled investors and the public.”a
Diplomacy
US reportedly floated NATO membership for Ukraine in land-for-peace talks
US President Donald Trump’s son-in-law and envoy Jared Kushner has discussed granting Ukraine NATO membership in exchange for territorial concessions during closed-door talks over the past several months, The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reported, citing sources.
Once considered unworkable, the idea has come up in recent months during various discussions between European officials and Kushner alongside fellow special envoy Steve Witkoff.
Sources said Kushner discussed the possibility with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and European officials at an airport in Dublin last week.
The issue was also raised last week during at least one meeting in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), where Kushner and Witkoff held talks with Ukrainian, European and Russian representatives.
An unnamed European leader noted that the idea had also been discussed during a telephone call in August.
US put forward two possible scenarios in talks
According to sources, the US presented two possible scenarios in recent discussions.
The first scenario envisages Ukraine giving up Donbas in return for NATO membership.
The second option involves freezing the conflict along the front line and providing Kyiv with security guarantees.
The WSJ reported that it remains unclear how seriously US negotiators are taking the idea or whether President Donald Trump has changed his stance on Ukraine’s NATO membership.
Last year, Trump agreed with US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth that Ukraine’s membership in the alliance and a return to its pre-2014 borders were “unrealistic”.
European capitals reacted differently
Following talks in Berlin, French President Emmanuel Macron said the time had come to discuss Ukraine’s NATO membership.
According to the newspaper’s sources, although the issue came up during the talks, the German side was reluctant to take it forward.
German Chancellor Friedrich Merz told aides that Ukraine would not join the alliance in his lifetime.
Bloomberg also reported this week that Washington had asked Kyiv whether it was prepared to recognize Donbas as Russian territory in exchange for NATO membership.
Ukrainian leader Zelenskyy, however, insists on a return to the 1991 borders as a condition for negotiations.
Zelenskyy previously said the US had for the first time asked Kyiv about the possibility of NATO membership in exchange for withdrawing from Donbas.
Kremlin rejects freezing the front line
Commenting on Zelenskyy’s remarks, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said: “In the interests of the peace process, we maintain our position that disclosing the details of discussions between us and the Americans is inappropriate.”
The Kremlin has repeatedly rejected freezing the conflict along the line of contact.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said the option did not satisfy Moscow because Europe would still refuse to recognize Russian-controlled territories as part of Russia.
“The West is now proposing the following: stopping where the line of contact is, establishing a ceasefire rather than a long-term peace; moreover, it is being loudly declared that after such a halt or cessation of hostilities, neither Ukraine nor Europe will recognize the territories under Russian control as territory of the Russian Federation in accordance with the Constitution,” Lavrov said.
Russia demands that Ukraine abandon its NATO bid and withdraw its forces from the Donbas, Zaporizhzhia and Kherson regions as conditions for a ceasefire.
Late last year, Russian President Vladimir Putin said that given the pace of Russian advances in Donbas, Moscow’s interest in a Ukrainian military withdrawal from those territories had “dropped to zero”.
In 2024, Putin stated that Moscow and Kyiv had agreed on Ukraine’s independence with NATO membership ruled out, but added that Kyiv had abandoned the neutrality principles in its declaration of independence and enshrined the goal of joining the alliance in its Constitution.
-
America2 weeks agoUS midterms see 97 young winners as Gen Z representation triples
-
Europe2 weeks agoUK and Germany expand military pact with focus on Russian frontier
-
America2 weeks agoNvidia investigates CEO Jensen Huang over link to Chinese spy
-
America2 weeks agoUS secures 35% stake in Venezuelan firm NABEP under 50-year deal
-
Europe2 weeks agoGeorge Szamuely dissects European decline and strategic rifts with US
-
Opinion2 weeks agoThe Mecca Defence Agreement, the Ottoman Empire, and the facts
-
Opinion2 weeks agoSettle, deny, seal: Britain’s formula for colonial torture, from Kenya to Cyprus — 1
-
America1 week agoAbsent Democrats derail floor vote on Pete Hegseth impeachment
