Diplomacy
US strikes fail to break Iran as regional anchors rise, Dr. Moeini says
The strategic miscalculations of US military intervention in the Middle East have accelerated the emergence of a post-American regional order anchored by indigenous powers, according to Dr. Arta Moeini, Research Director and Managing Director at the Institute for Peace and Diplomacy (IPD).
In an extensive interview with journalist Sarp Sinan Hacir for the Turkish foreign policy platform Harici, Moeini delivered a comprehensive realist critique of Washington’s ongoing confrontation with Tehran, the destabilising nature of unconditional US support for Israel, and the systemic rise of regional security frameworks such as the Mecca Agreement.
Evaluating the trajectory of US-Iran hostilities following the escalation of the conflict, Moeini stated that Washington faces acute strategic dilemmas largely of its own making.
“Iran has lost its fear of American primacy”
Discussing the operational reality of the military exchange, Moeini highlighted a fundamental psychological turning point across the region.
“Iran was under a lot of pressure before the war started,” Moeini stated, identifying the hostilities as an outgrowth of earlier escalations. “This is first of all a continuation of the 12-Day War. There was a pause and then the real war happened. But Iran had never, despite all the rhetoric and bluster and the kind of cold war that happened since 1979 and the early 80s, engaged itself in a full-on conflict, hot, kinetic war with the United States.”
Moeini argued that the direct clash stripped Washington of its primary psychological leverage: “The fact that that happened and the fact that Iran lived to see another day has meant that it has lost its fear of American primacy and military supremacy. And that in itself is freeing, because for a long time Iran felt bullied and intimidated and just wanted to survive. Now Iran wants to not only survive, but to reset the picture and to begin to start to thrive in its own region.”
With approximately 50,000 US troops stationed across the Middle East, Moeini observed that Tehran is actively pressing Washington to dismantle its forward posture and abandon the strategic architecture established decades ago under the Carter Doctrine.
“After the Iranian revolution happened, the neocons in both the Carter and the Reagan administrations started thinking through how to project American power outside of their traditional allied networks,” Moeini explained. “Iran used to be one of America’s enforcers in the region. Without Iran, it was just not possible. America made preparations in the 80s to have a capability for counter-strikes and power projection, but also a more permanent presence in the Middle East.”
Following the 1991 Gulf War, US basing expanded across the Persian Gulf, leading to prolonged entanglements. Moeini noted: “We ended up with 9/11, then we ended up with endless wars in the Middle East. There is a lot of pressure from inside America for us to withdraw and retrench from a region that is at best secondary to American interests.”
Highlighting US energy independence, Moeini stressed: “We are no longer reliant on the oil and energy that comes from the Persian Gulf. Most of these shipments go to China and Europe anyway. Why should America be the security enforcer? It is better if there is a new balance of power based in the region’s historical conventional powers.”
Addressing policy debates within Washington, Moeini pointed out that figures like Joe Kent, the administration’s former counterterrorism director, have argued that a full US military withdrawal would neutralise Tehran’s primary asymmetric advantage.
“If America basically leaves its bases and decides to leave the Middle East, then Iran really does not have much that it can do,” Moeini observed. “It actually takes away Iranian leverage.”
“America has lost strategically”
Assessing the policy paths available to US President Donald Trump, Moeini outlined four distinct options, asserting that military escalation and economic containment are incapable of delivering US objectives.
“The political context, the political situation, Donald Trump’s own psychology and ego prevent him from just doing this without having a pretext to say, ‘I have accomplished something,'” Moeini noted regarding an unconditioned withdrawal.
Rejecting the calls from neoconservative factions to double down through intensified aerial bombardments or tactical strikes, Moeini remarked: “Somebody said the gloves are coming off, as if the gloves haven’t come off so far. There is really not much else that America can do other than putting troops on the ground and doing a real invasion, and I don’t think that is on the cards either.”
Similarly, Moeini dismissed the prospect of economic warfare collapsing the Iranian state: “The third option is to keep this blockade in place, keep the Iranian economy under a squeeze. This is something they have been saying for 47 years. Iran has already been under weeks and months of a naval blockade, and nothing has happened. This is wishful thinking in Washington.”
Moeini advocated for a fourth option: a tacit, realism-based strategic accommodation.
“You require the two sides through back channels to acknowledge the new reality, which is that America is no longer going to be the dominant power in the Middle East,” Moeini said. “Trillions of dollars and thousands of people have died, and what do we have to show for it? There might be an opportunity to acknowledge this and use it as a moment to recalibrate America’s posture in the world.”
Moeini characterised the resulting dynamic as a potential strategic pivot: “America has had tactical successes, but it definitely has lost strategically. But it might be able to turn that strategic defeat into a grand strategic bargain that actually serves America. I call it a reverse Pyrrhic victory.”
Under such an arrangement, Moeini explained, regional transit would stabilise: “Iran would have a bounded sphere of interest and obligation in the Persian Gulf. The shipments keep going, energy keeps flowing, and there is no threat to the global economy. Countries in the region, especially Türkiye, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt, work with Iran for a new regional arrangement which ultimately will stabilise the region.”
On the nuclear issue, Moeini argued: “US companies could do business with Iran and actually have a sense of monitoring on the nuclear issue if the actual American threat of military action is removed. The Iranians believe they can contain Israel, but they always had an issue with an extra-regional superpower being so active in the region. Removing US military presence disarms Iranian propaganda and removes the source of regional tension.”
Responding to neoconservative assertions that US forward deployment is required to insulate global energy transit and European economies from potential Iranian disruption, Moeini rejected the rationale.
“Before the US aggression and attack, the oil was flowing and the Strait of Hormuz was open,” Moeini stated. “If the result of this military action is that Iran charges a security or environmental fee of 5% to 7% that it shares with Oman, it brings predictability back to the markets. Businesses just want to know what price they have to pay.”
Moeini warned of compounding economic consequences in the absence of a settlement, pointing to market pressures and maritime bottlenecks in the Bab el-Mandeb, the Red Sea, and the Suez Canal: “Scott Bessent has done all he can do to keep oil prices below $100. But if there is no resolution, oil can become much more expensive per barrel—$150, $170, or even higher.”
“The state in Iran will not collapse in 72 hours”
Moeini identified profound intelligence and operational miscalculations at the highest levels of the US administration regarding Iran’s internal durability and state capacity.
“The United States has bombed Iran more than 13,000 times with large bombs of high significance and damage,” Moeini noted. “Yet Iran has withheld. It has established deterrence by punishment through its missile and drone programmes, and deterrence by denial through passive security measures, deep mountain facilities, and defensive resilience.”
“I just do not see a future in which Iran capitulates, surrenders, and comes to the Americans with its tail between its legs,” Moeini stressed. “President Donald Trump willfully ignored US intelligence for Israeli intelligence and promises of an easy victory a la Venezuela. The administration believed that the Iranian state would collapse in 48 to 72 hours. This is insane to say out loud, but it was what they believed, and that is why we are in this mess.”
Drawing historical parallels to other enduring regional entities, Moeini stated: “Iran is an enduring regional power like Türkiye. Putting aside for a second that Türkiye is a NATO member, do you think the United States could topple the Turkish government? Zero chance. Türkiye is a Byzantine, sophisticated, modern state, and Iran is very similar.”
Moeini disclosed that Israeli strategists sought a broader fragmentation of the Iranian state: “The Israelis wanted chaos and the Syrianisation of Iran. With the help of the Pakistanis and the Turks, this did not happen. The borders in the west and east in Baluchistan and Kurdistan were under heavy surveillance and control by Pakistan and Türkiye.”
“Aerial campaigns do nothing to topple regimes,” Moeini added. “The plan was to introduce Mossad-backed Kurdish militias from Erbil, along with the MEK, to take border cities and ignite a civil war. This was a horrible plan. You do not want to destabilise regional anchors like Türkiye, Iran, Egypt, and Saudi Arabia, or nuclear-armed states like Pakistan.”
“The special relationship is at an inflection point”
Addressing the US-Israel strategic relationship, Moeini stated that ties have reached an unsustainable contradiction.
“The relationship is at an inflection point and a breaking point at the same time,” Moeini argued. “We saw the zenith of the special relationship with the war—America actively conducted offensive operations on behalf of another state, as Marco Rubio and other administration figures openly stated. Yet as a result of the war’s failure, we are seeing the nadir of the relationship.”
Moeini observed that domestic fatigue across the American public is accelerating: “The American public is sick and tired of Israel influencing its politics. America is supposed to be the patron, yet the vassal is telling the patron what to do.”
“We are deindustrialising, undercutting healthcare, and borrowing from future generations to fund reckless adventures continents away, whether funding the war in Ukraine or over decades in the Middle East,” Moeini said. “Warmongers like Marc Thiessen do not care where the war is; they just need a war and an enemy.”
Invoking foundational American diplomatic principles, Moeini stated: “A sane country participates in ventures when interests align, and abstains when they diverge. There is no permanent friendship and there should be no permanent enmities. That was the advice of George Washington. Yet we have maintained permanent alliances and unconditional support. Our relations can no longer be dictated by World War II and events from a century ago.”
Citing assessments by Israeli foreign policy analyst Nimrod Novik and writings by Jonathan Touval, Moeini noted: “Israel is weaker today, more militant, and a worse-off society because of America’s unconditional support. The extremism and extrajudicial policies under Benjamin Netanyahu are enabled because they believe they hold an exceptionalist card and that a ‘big daddy’ will always intervene.”
“Countries like Taiwan, Ukraine, and Israel are small in territory and demographics; they will never become regional anchors in the way that Türkiye, Iran, Saudi Arabia, or Egypt are,” Moeini observed.
Reflecting on internal administration politics and the standing of foreign policy realists, Moeini confirmed that while figures like former National Security Advisor Andy Baker resigned for personal reasons rather than being ousted, institutional advisory channels have degraded.
“Realists got the most personnel into the US government than ever before, yet they were not successful in directing policy,” Moeini said. “Donald Trump does not operate through formal government process. The National Security Council is effectively defunct. US intelligence under Tulsi Gabbard at the DNI and the CIA accurately assessed that Iran would be resilient, yet their assessments were bypassed for outside television commentators like Mark Levin.”
Despite current setbacks, Moeini expressed conviction that demographic and political shifts among younger Americans ensure the long-term dominance of realism: “Millennials and Gen Z do not want a Global American Empire. They want internal restoration, reindustrialisation, infrastructure, and fiscal discipline. Institutionalised globalism is dying off. Realism is ascendant.”
“The region has rejected the Abraham Accords”
Turning to regional diplomacy and the trilateral Mecca Agreement signed between Saudi Arabia, Türkiye, and Pakistan, Moeini described the pact as a foundational pillar of an autonomous West Asian security architecture.
“The post-American West Asia is creating new arrangements for security management in full rejection of the Abraham Accords,” Moeini said. “This is an elastic defence pact that represents the nucleus of the ‘ME5’—a concert of five primary regional powers comprising Türkiye, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Pakistan, and Egypt.”
Moeini dismissed comparisons between the Mecca Agreement and Western collective defence structures: “I do not like the comparison to NATO. That is an anachronistic, Anglo-Western framework that presumes a fixed enemy. The Mecca Agreement is not aimed at Iran, nor is it explicitly aimed at Israel. It is an alternative, indigenous security arrangement akin to the 19th-century Concert of Europe under Metternich, designed to manage regional affairs and resist extra-regional military intervention.”
Moeini explained that regional states recognise that outside interference is the primary driver of instability: “All five regional powers want economic stability and growth—whether through Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030, Turkish strategic initiatives, or Iranian economic restoration. The major regional hubs—the Turkic world, the Iranian plateau, and the Arab sphere—are establishing agency over their own security.”
Moeini concluded by outlining the strategic imperative confronting Israel in a post-unipolar Middle East.
“Israel can never be a regional hegemon,” Moeini stated. “The Abraham Accords represented an Israeli-first, hierarchical construct that the region has rejected. When Donald Trump offered nuclear cooperation to Riyadh conditioned on joining the Abraham Accords, Saudi Arabia responded by signing the Mecca Agreement.”
“Israel faces a clear choice: continue an unsustainable military confrontation, or return to David Ben-Gurion’s periphery doctrine by seeking functional coexistence with regional anchors like Türkiye and Iran,” Moeini concluded. “If Israel chooses integration within regional realities rather than serving as an outpost for extra-regional power projection, even Tehran would move toward tacit accommodation. The future of West Asia belongs to a concert of regional powers.”
Diplomacy
US and allies sign pact to shield AI supply chains from China
The US and several countries, including Japan, Australia, Israel and the United Kingdom, have agreed to establish a joint list of critical technologies and supply chains supporting artificial intelligence.
US Under Secretary of State for Economic Affairs Jacob Helberg told the Financial Times (FT) that South Korea, India, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates have also signed the “San Francisco Declaration on the Secure Foundations of Lasting Prosperity”.
Germany, Sweden, the Netherlands and the European Commission are also expected to sign the declaration next week.
The declaration forms part of the US-led “Pax Silica” initiative, which aims to strengthen AI-related supply chains, including semiconductors, critical minerals and energy infrastructure, as Washington and its partners seek to reduce vulnerabilities and deepen cooperation amid growing competition with Beijing.
Helberg said the agreement recognizes that the technologies and infrastructure supporting AI development often span multiple countries, making supply chain security a shared responsibility.
The initiative emerged as President Donald Trump prepares to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit to be held in Shenzhen, China.
Washington accuses Beijing of failing to fulfil its commitments under a trade truce the leaders reached in late 2025.
Helberg said the agreement would help participating countries identify the sensitive technologies and critical infrastructure needed to develop what Trump calls “superintelligence” and enable information sharing on areas where supply chains need to be diversified.
The declaration states that economic security is fundamental to national security and calls for stronger safeguards against the theft or unauthorized transfer of technologies that could give adversarial actors a military or intelligence advantage.
The agreement also provides for the establishment of working groups to address vulnerabilities in AI supply chains and develop economic hubs to attract investment into related sectors.
The initiative is part of a broader US effort to reduce reliance on China for critical materials, particularly rare earth elements, as Washington seeks to diversify supply sources for itself and its allies.
Diplomacy
NATO cancels 2027 summit over Ukraine and Iran rifts
NATO is cancelling its 2027 leaders’ summit planned for Albania due to disagreements over defence spending and the wars in Iran and Ukraine, the Associated Press (AP) reported.
Albanian Prime Minister Edi Rama said alliance countries have not yet agreed on a date for the next summit, but confirmed the meeting will not take place in 2027.
NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte also confirmed that the alliance is not bound to a fixed schedule and that leaders meet “when necessary”.
NATO is also reducing the number of ministerial-level meetings.
No defence ministers’ meeting was held in October this year, and none is planned for October 2027.
Alliance foreign ministers will meet only once next year instead of twice.
NATO explains these changes as “restructuring”.
US policies and Iran war divide the alliance
One reason for the disagreements has been US policies under President Donald Trump.
The US administration is demanding that allies increase defence spending, criticizing them for not sufficiently supporting the war against Iran, and questioning Washington’s previous commitments to European security.
At the summit held in Ankara in July, allies agreed on a 70 billion euro aid package for Ukraine for 2026 and pledged to maintain a similar level in 2027.
However, Italy opposed the second point.
The NATO Secretary General also proposed making military support spending for Kyiv mandatory at 0.25% of gross domestic product, but this initiative failed.
According to The Telegraph’s sources, only seven of the 32 NATO countries backed the proposal, while countries including the UK, France, Spain, Italy, and Canada opposed it.
Divisions grow over Ukraine aid and membership
Furthermore, in November, Bulgaria refused to provide military support to Ukraine and join the European Union’s (EU) new aid package, while Poland suspended financing for purchasing US weapons for the Ukrainian Armed Forces.
Negotiations conducted by Trump’s special envoys with Moscow behind allies’ backs are also causing an additional rift in the alliance.
The US and Europe also hold different views on Ukraine’s prospects of joining NATO.
While the Trump administration and Trump himself oppose this accession, the Ukrainian President stated on 14 November that the Americans had asked him whether he was ready to give up Donbas in exchange for alliance membership.
In contrast to Washington’s shifting line, some European politicians insist on Kyiv’s unconditional integration.
French President Emmanuel Macron said on 15 November: “Ukraine’s place is inside the alliance.”
Some countries, such as Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia, share the same stance.
Diplomacy
CSTO strips Armenia of voting rights over two-year budget debt
Members of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) have stripped Armenia of its voting rights and its ability to appoint representatives to official positions due to a two-year debt to the organization’s budget.
Kremlin Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said, “This decision was taken based on the organization’s charter due to Armenia’s failure to fulfil its obligations for several years.”
Prior to the CSTO leaders’ summit in Moscow, Peskov had stated that member states would “react” to the Caucasus country’s non-participation in the organization’s activities.
Ahead of the Moscow summit, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan said his country’s “interest has run out” regarding the CSTO. Through his press spokesperson, he announced that he would travel to Türkiye on 11 November to attend the United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31) instead of going to Russia.
The CSTO leaders’ meeting was held with the participation of Russian President Vladimir Putin alongside the leaders of Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan.
The leaders jointly took the decision to revoke Armenia’s voting rights.
At the conclusion of the meeting, the participants also signed a joint declaration.
The declaration stated: “We confirm our unconditional commitment to the goals set out in the CSTO treaty and charter towards creating favourable and stable conditions for the comprehensive development of member states.”
Pashinyan had frozen Yerevan’s de facto participation in the CSTO in February 2024, citing the organization’s failure to aid the Armenian side during the armed clashes in Nagorno-Karabakh in September 2023.
Having referred to the CSTO as a “soap-bubble alliance” since that time, Pashinyan accused the organization’s members of “planning war” together with Baku. He stated that Armenia would not return to active work within the alliance at least “over the next five years”, adding that he would welcome it if the country were expelled from membership.
Relations between Armenia and Russia grew tense once again in the spring of 2026, after Yerevan moved closer to the European Union (EU) and the Kremlin responded with a trade war.
In May, Pashinyan refused to travel to Moscow to attend the Victory Day parade and declared that he did not support Russia on the Ukraine issue.
In response, Putin called on Yerevan to determine its foreign policy course through a referendum, advising Armenian authorities not to forget the fate of Ukraine.
-
America1 week agoUS midterms see 97 young winners as Gen Z representation triples
-
Diplomacy2 weeks agoSecular dress code dispute exposes deeper Türkiye-Azerbaijan strains
-
Europe1 week agoEU urges citizens to prepare 72-hour survival kits for crises
-
Asia2 weeks agoChina expands Africa arms sales, displacing France and Western rivals
-
Diplomacy2 weeks agoProtesters storm Kyiv site holding soldiers over torture allegations
-
Europe2 weeks agoPro-Ukraine Republicans in US Congress dwindle after departures
-
Europe2 weeks agoLow EU gas stocks risk stoking global prices, IEA report warns
-
America2 weeks agoICE contractors steer over $12m to US campaigns ahead of midterms
