Connect with us

Asia

Türkiye’s BRICS bid discussed at Shanghai University

Published

on

On 24 September, the Institute of Global Studies of Shanghai University organised a workshop on ‘Türkiye’s Re-Asia Initiative’.

Moderated by Prof. Guo Changgang, Director of the Centre for Turkish Studies at Shanghai University, the workshop discussed China and Türkiye’s foreign policies, the rising global South, the BRICS agenda and Türkiye’s membership bid.

Opening the event, Prof. Guo Changgang said: “As Ankara is applying to join BRICS, it is a good time to talk about Türkiye’s Asia policy,” highlighting the Re-Asia Initiative.

“Türkiye’s efforts to join the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) and participate in ASEAN show that Türkiye has adopted a ‘pendulum’ position between the West and the East,” said Prof. Dr. Gürol Baba of Ankara Social Sciences University. Gürol Baba said Türkiye’s move to join BRICS will make it a more ‘visible’ actor in the region: “Türkiye is an active middle power. It should cooperate with like-minded powers. For example, Türkiye is a founding member of the MIKTA group. BRICS is also a place where Türkiye can find like-minded countries. Baba said Türkiye wanted to keep East and West together in its foreign policy.

Prof Zou Zhigiang of Fudan University said: ‘Türkiye is changing its Asia policy. This is because an Asia that is economically and technologically confident, competitive and rising in every sense cannot be ignored. Türkiye is currently seeking to increase its engagement in the region. President Erdoğan attended the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation summit in 2022 for the first time as a NATO country. It has also been confirmed that Türkiye has applied to join BRICS,” he said. Prof Zou summed up why Türkiye attaches such importance to Asia in 4 points:

  1. Accumulated frustration with the West and the European Union. It is now clear that Türkiye’s EU membership will not happen in the near future.

  2. Türkiye is seeking strategic autonomy. It wants to be a central power in the world and pursue a balanced policy. It wants to be a centre between East and West and not give up its NATO membership.

  3. The growing global influence and attractiveness of the SCO and BRICS.

  4. Türkiye’s domestic economy faces challenges. New economic markets and capital inflows are vital for Türkiye.

Prof Zhou Shixin of the Shanghai Institute of International Studies commented on China’s Asia policy:

“China is seen by the US as the biggest threat, so it is blocked and ostracised by the US and some of its allies. China-US relations are one of the most important factors driving the regional power shift and order transition in the Asia-Pacific. China is expanding its presence and increasing its influence in the Asia-Pacific. China is acting as a modern and sovereign country, making great efforts to defend its territorial integrity and sovereign independence and to achieve national reunification. China also seeks peaceful and equal coexistence and interaction with the US, but does not seek to coerce the US. China seeks to strengthen security and economic relations with more regional countries on the basis of the principles of ‘friendship, sincerity, mutual benefit and inclusiveness’. China seeks to manage and resolve territorial disputes with its neighbours primarily through bilateral diplomatic consultations and negotiations”.

Commenting on Türkiye’s Asia Re-entry Initiative, Prof. Zhou said that Ankara has demonstrated its willingness to pursue a multi-dimensional foreign policy based on the Strategic Depth Doctrine and made the following suggestions: “Türkiye can focus more on Southeast Asia rather than South Asia and Northeast Asia, Türkiye can interact with Asia-Pacific countries as a sovereign country, not as a NATO member, even with Japan and South Korea. Türkiye could promote more economic cooperation rather than security cooperation, Türkiye could apply to join the ASEAN Regional Forum as an Asian country, and Türkiye could negotiate more free trade agreements with Asia-Pacific countries beyond South Korea (1 May 2013), Malaysia (1 August 2015) and Singapore (1 October 2017) before joining the EU. As a result, China is willing to help Türkiye further coordinate with some regional countries.”

Prof Zhou Yiqi of the Shanghai Institute of International Studies spoke about China’s Middle East policy:

“There are four major parties in the Middle East: Arab countries, Israel, Iran and Türkiye. China has strengthened its relations with most of the major powers there. However, Türkiye remains the only party that has not yet signed a partnership agreement with China. Diplomatic relations between the two: Strategic Cooperation Relations. Although relations between China and Israel are rather poor, there is still a relationship of innovative partnership. In addition, China has successfully negotiated the conflict between Iran and Saudi Arabia. China’s partnership between these two countries has become a bridge that brings them together.

The traditional stereotype is that China is only interested in economic issues and is a free rider on security in the region. However, after its mediation between Iran and Saudi Arabia and its efforts to bring peace to Gaza, China has become an active player in Middle East security issues. However, this still differs from US efforts to use the alliance as a bargaining chip. China has always been quite fair in the Middle East, which has earned it trust. But it is also on the side of justice, for example on the Palestinian issue.”

Commenting on Türkiye’s Re-Asia Initiative, Prof. Zhou Yiqi said: “I think it is important for Türkiye to improve its relations with China, because China-Türkiye relations are even weaker than China-Israel relations. China is looking for stability in the face of apparent uncertainty. But I don’t understand why the foreign minister went back to Türkiye and suddenly raised taxes on electric cars imported from China. Such issues have become a hot topic on Chinese social media and this is definitely not positive for people-to-people understanding,” he said.

Dr Selçuk Aydın of Boğaziçi University commented on Türkiye’s relations with Asia:

“The origins of modern Türkiye go back to the early 19th century. The biggest event of that period was the abolition of the Janissaries. In other words, while the Ottoman Empire was undergoing a transformation, this process was expressed with a ‘new’ term. If we look back to the 1920s, there were again discussions about ‘New Türkiye’. When Erdoğan came to power, all the news was about ‘New Türkiye’. In fact, Asia is nothing new for Türkiye; it already has historical, cultural and religious links. I think Dr Serdar has been working on Uighur and Xinjiang issues. Historically, this region has been very connected and interacted with Türkiye.

Secondly, Türkiye’s participation in the Belt and Road Initiative is a great initiative. There is a mystery in Türkiye about China and in China about Türkiye. How is Türkiye perceived? For China, the concept of Türkiye is probably limited to NATO. Then there is the Xinjiang issue. There are two important issues that hinder Türkiye’s cooperation with China.

The first step we need to discuss is Türkiye’s dissatisfaction with what the US is forcing it to do in the Middle East. Especially the Syria incident. That was a turning point in diplomacy. Another example is the FETO case. Gulen had a close relationship with the US and there was a coup attempt. After this incident, Türkiye’s diplomatic direction changed. After the Arab Spring, Türkiye realised that the US did not support liberal movements in the Middle East, but only focused on its own interests. Subsequently, Türkiye became more involved in Middle Eastern affairs, for example by mobilising its military abroad in Syria, Azerbaijan and elsewhere.

We need to analyse Türkiye’s foreign policy from these perspectives. First, history, which is also intertwined with religion. The Ottoman Empire was the centre of the Caliphate. The second is the racial dimension, which also bears traces of the late Ottoman Empire. Turkish consulates are therefore the main pillar of Turkish foreign policy. The third pillar of Turkish policy is the promotion of a non-Western approach. This is related to the foundations of modern Türkiye and is very anti-colonialist. At the same time, Türkiye is geographically close to Western countries and has historically cooperated with them.

Türkiye’s neighbours are often in civil war or conflict. So Türkiye has to look to Asia, because China has incredible lessons to teach in that region. China may be the only superpower that wants peace in the Middle East.”

Commenting on Türkiye-China relations, Dr Serdar Yurtçiçek said:

“Professor Yiqi mentioned that there are four important powers in the Middle East (Türkiye, Arabia, Iran and Israel) and although China has very good relations with three of them, it has not been able to improve its relations with Türkiye. The reason for this is the Uighur issue, as Selçuk mentioned earlier. Since 2016, I have been living in China and researching Türkiye’s China policy. During this time, I have met many Chinese academics and politicians. The conclusion I have drawn from my experience and research is that the most important issue between Türkiye and China is the Uyghur issue, and unless this issue is resolved, all other areas of cooperation cannot be built in a relationship of mutual trust. Last year, former ambassador Emin Önen said: ‘There is mutual understanding on 99 points in Türkiye-China relations, but let’s not agree on one point. This should not hinder the development of bilateral relations’. Prof. Yang Chen said that China wants to improve its relations with Türkiye, but this point is as important as the other 99 points and the two countries should keep their mutual promises. That point is the Uighur issue. And it is clear that Turkish academics and politicians do not understand how important the Xinjiang issue is for China and that it is a non-negotiable issue in terms of national sovereignty.

After the Second World War, Turkish-Chinese relations developed largely within the foreign policy boundaries drawn by the United States. In particular, the fight against China in the Korean Civil War and Türkiye’s eventual accession to NATO led to Uighur figures such as Isa Yusuf Alptekin and Mehmet Emin Buğra defecting to Türkiye, making Türkiye a centre for anti-China Uighur separatist organisations. Even diplomatic relations between Türkiye and China only started after the US established diplomatic relations with China.

The situation was no different before the Second World War. Türkiye prioritised its friendship with the Soviets in its foreign policy and was wary of taking any steps that might anger the Soviets. For example, in 1944, Türkiye and the Republic of China almost signed a treaty of friendship, but Türkiye cancelled the treaty at the last minute so as not to anger the Soviets. This was because Türkiye had serious problems with the Soviets, especially the issue of the Straits Convention. The situation was similar in China. Xinjiang was largely under Soviet control. According to a Turkish diplomat, if a Chinese official wanted to go to Xinjiang, he first had to get permission from the Soviet consul in Kashgar.

Today, for the first time, there is a possibility of strategic relations between China and Türkiye without the shadow of a third country. Türkiye’s application for BRICS membership should be seen in this context.”

Asia

Japan proposes Asian version of IEA to manage regional oil reserves

Published

on

Japan has proposed establishing an “Asian version” of the International Energy Agency (IEA) to manage strategic oil reserves and protect the region against energy shocks caused by war or climate change.

Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi proposed on Tuesday the creation of a regional task force to oversee releases from emergency stockpiles, similar to the Paris-based organisation founded in response to the 1973 oil market shock.

Speaking in the Philippines at a meeting of the Asia Zero Emission Community (AZEC), Japan’s version of China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), Takaichi said they view this new entity, to be named the “Asian Petroleum Security Task Force”, as “equivalent to an Asian version of the IEA”.

She also proposed a parallel plan to use idle oil tanks in Japan to store crude reserves for the rest of Asia.

The IEA is advising the Japanese government on a framework for a regional system and plans to open a new office in Tokyo.

The proposals aim to increase oil stockpiles across South-East Asia, which was hit particularly hard by the oil shock.

Japan held stockpiles equivalent to 250 days of oil consumption before the US and Israeli strike on Iran in February.

However, its reliance on South-East Asia for oil derivatives such as naphtha and plastics left Japanese manufacturers facing shortages of products ranging from coloured ink to surgical gloves.

Takaichi indicated that Middle Eastern oil companies would play an important role in supply, saying the plan aims to “increase the economic and energy resilience of these countries” by reducing Gulf states’ dependence on the Strait of Hormuz to access global markets.

Amrita Sen, co-founder of the consultancy Energy Aspects, said: “This is an existential issue for the Middle East. They need storage where their consumers are. They want to make sure this [disruption] does not happen again.”

Japan already has joint stockpiling agreements with Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, and Kuwait.

Under these agreements, oil storage tanks are leased in exchange for priority access in emergencies.

Takaichi said Japan’s surplus storage capacity could support a shared South-East Asian stockpile championed by the Philippines, saving Manila the cost of building infrastructure.

Officials in the Philippines, which sources almost all its oil from the Middle East, say Singapore, Indonesia, and Malaysia have agreed to maintain oil stockpiles under the proposal, and the UAE has expressed interest in participating.

Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr said on Tuesday that Manila was building its strategic oil reserves, “but stockpiling is not enough”.

Speaking at the AZEC meeting, held on the sidelines of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) leaders’ summit in Manila, he said: “Sustainable and lasting energy security requires oil-consuming and oil-producing countries to act in unison.”

According to a study by the Economic Research Institute for ASEAN and East Asia, a Jakarta-based think tank established by Japan’s Ministry of Economy, South-East Asia’s oil reserves are estimated to cover 30 days of consumption, whereas the IEA recommends holding reserves equivalent to 90 days of net imports.

The institute estimated the annual cost of building an additional 60 days of reserves across ASEAN’s 11 member countries at about $2.2 billion, proposing a hybrid model comprising national reserves, joint importer-exporter stockpiles, and international storage managed via a “ticketing” system.

Japan and South Korea are the only IEA members in Asia. The IEA is open to OECD countries that hold reserves equivalent to 90 days of net imports and are willing to share reserve data.

Continue Reading

Asia

Xi urges free trade against protectionism at APEC CEO Summit

Published

on

Chinese President Xi Jinping warned against unilateralism and protectionism during an address at the APEC CEO Summit held in Shenzhen. Expressing support for a multipolar world order and economic globalisation, Xi announced that China would open its market further to global companies. “History shows us that opening doors brings progress, while closing them leads to backwardness,” Xi said.

Heads of state and government addressed business leaders at the high-level forum held as part of the APEC summit, which China is hosting for the first time since 2014.

Chinese President Xi Jinping and other world leaders delivered speeches on Wednesday at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) CEO Summit in Shenzhen.

Numerous business representatives, including prominent executives from technology and other emerging sectors, are attending this year’s event, which marks the first APEC summit hosted by China.

In his keynote address at the APEC CEO Summit, Xi delivered key messages on the future of the global economic order, China’s development strategy, and the strengthening of economic cooperation across the Asia-Pacific.

Pointing out that the global economy has lost growth momentum and that unilateralism and protectionism have become increasingly widespread, Xi noted that global trade has nevertheless continued to expand and breakthroughs in new technologies have accelerated.

Emphasising that the world is passing through a critical juncture, Xi raised several questions:

“What is happening in the world? What should we do as the Asia-Pacific? Should we open our doors or close them? Should we work together, or against each other? Should we adapt to change, or insist on old methods?”

Describing these questions as the defining issues of the era, the Chinese leader called on APEC nations to deepen cooperation.

‘An equal and orderly multipolar world’

Xi said the environment of regional stability has played a decisive role in turning the Asia-Pacific into one of the key engines of global economic growth in recent years.

Stating that global conditions are becoming increasingly complex, Xi stressed that the post-war international order must be preserved.

The Chinese leader said, “As external conditions become more complex, it becomes even more vital to preserve the post-war international order and to promote an equal and orderly multipolar world, along with inclusive economic globalisation that benefits all.”

Xi stated that regional disputes must be resolved through dialogue and consultation, adding that solidarity and cooperation form the foundation of lasting peace and stability in the Asia-Pacific.

‘Opening doors brings progress, closing them brings backwardness’

Devoting a significant portion of his address to free trade and economic integration, Xi called for the preservation of the multilateral trading system centred on the World Trade Organization (WTO).

“History shows us that opening doors brings progress, while closing them leads to backwardness,” Xi said, drawing attention to the importance of the uninterrupted operation of global industrial and supply chains.

Xi urged progress in efforts to establish the Free Trade Area of the Asia-Pacific and called for increased cooperation in cross-border e-commerce and digital trade.

The Chinese leader said artificial intelligence and the digital economy have become new driving forces of regional growth, stressing that partnerships in science and technology must be strengthened.

Chinese economy grew %4.6 in first three quarters

Recalling that China’s 15th Five-Year Plan for economic and social development has commenced, Xi said the national economy maintains its resilience.

Announcing that the Chinese economy grew %4.6 in the first three quarters of the year, Xi noted that innovation-driven growth and the green transition have gained pace.

Xi delivered the message that “the 15th Five-Year Plan is not merely China’s development roadmap, but also an invitation to cooperate that presents new opportunities for the Asia-Pacific and the world economy.”

Underlining that China is the world’s second-largest consumer market, Xi said the country possesses the world’s largest middle-income population and holds immense potential in terms of consumption and investment.

He noted that areas such as new energy vehicles, smart homes, elderly care services, and winter tourism offer fresh opportunities for foreign enterprises.

‘We will open the Chinese market further’

Xi announced that China will provide wider market access to the global business community.

Indicating that his country will not stop at lowering tariffs, Xi announced that regulatory reforms will also be implemented to facilitate foreign companies’ operations.

“China will not merely lower tariffs and broaden market access; it will go beyond that,” the Chinese leader said.

Stating that reforms will be introduced in areas including rules, regulations, and standards, Xi said operating conditions for foreign enterprises in the manufacturing sector will be improved, while opening up in the services sector will be expanded.

Xi stressed that they aim to establish a more stable and predictable business environment for foreign investors.

‘China stood against unilateralism and protectionism’

Recalling that China acceded to the WTO in 2001, Xi noted that all commitments assumed under membership have been fulfilled over the past 25 years.

Xi expressed that China has shared economic opportunities with other nations while pursuing its own development and has defended the multilateral trading system.

“China stood against unilateralism and protectionism and remained committed to true multilateralism,” Xi said, adding that Beijing will continue to support the defence of WTO rules and the reform of the organization.

The Chinese leader stressed that no matter how international conditions change, Beijing will not abandon its policy of mutually beneficial cooperation with other nations.

Touching upon the Belt and Road Initiative, Xi also invited Asia-Pacific companies to participate more actively in the project.

New economic cooperation initiative in the Asia-Pacific

Citing the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area, which includes Shenzhen, as an example, Xi proposed developing economic cooperation among the world’s major bay areas.

Announcing China’s support for the establishment of the World Bay Areas Economic Cooperation Alliance, Xi said this initiative would strengthen economic linkages between different regions.

Noting that Asia-Pacific nations differ in terms of history, culture, and levels of development, the Chinese leader expressed that policies taking national conditions into account should be adopted in economic cooperation rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.

Xi called for increased technical and economic cooperation targeting developing economies, as well as the deepening of joint work in areas such as transport, energy, public health, food security, and anti-corruption.

Concluding his address with a call to the Asia-Pacific business community, Xi invited companies to participate more actively in China’s reform and modernization process.

Xi said, “Let us join hands to overcome the challenges facing development through opening up, to give momentum to growth through innovation, and to deliver prosperity for all through cooperation.”

Continue Reading

Asia

China expands Africa arms sales, displacing France and Western rivals

Published

on

China is overtaking Western suppliers, particularly France, by expanding its exports to African nations beyond small arms, armoured vehicles, trucks, and artillery to include air defence systems, combat drones, and electronic warfare assets.

According to a report by the South China Morning Post, based on researchers and military movements across the region, African buyers are gravitating towards the advantages of quality and accessibility offered by the Beijing administration.

In April, four vehicles spotted in a Malian army convoy were identified by defence intelligence company Janes as Chinese-manufactured Yitian-L air defence systems.

In September, the Presidency of Burkina Faso published footage of military equipment inspections and testing.

Observers noted that the released footage featured a mobile surveillance radar and a missile launch vehicle belonging to the Sky Dragon family produced by Chinese company Norinco.

In August, Cote d’Ivoire also showcased Wing Loong II armed unmanned aerial vehicles procured under a contract signed in June 2024 with Chinese state-owned enterprise Catic.

A distinct shift is unfolding in the weapons procurement trajectory of Sahel countries that have ended defence cooperation with France and run into US security assistance restrictions.

Mali, Burkina Faso, and Niger formed the Alliance of Sahel States in September 2023, transitioning the structure into a confederation in July 2024.

Following the transfer of power to military authorities, these nations progressively severed ties with France and turned their attention towards new partnerships.

Western bans and budget constraints pave way for Beijing

David Shinn, a former US ambassador to Burkina Faso and Ethiopia and a specialist in China-Africa relations, pointed out that the quality of Chinese military equipment has risen and that Beijing is willing to enter markets where the West hesitates.

“Unlike many Western countries, China will sell military equipment to any country so long as it is not under a United Nations sanction,” Shinn said.

Experts speaking to the newspaper stated that high-technology defence systems, previously purchased mainly from the West and accessible to only a few countries on the continent, are now being shipped more frequently to Africa by China.

Katarina Djokic, a researcher with the Arms Transfers Programme at the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI), said affordable pricing, including maintenance costs, plays a critical role in procurement choices.

Djokic noted that countries maintaining good relations with the West also procure weapons from China.

According to SIPRI assessments, shipments to African nations have not yet reached a volume large enough to fundamentally alter China’s overall arms export figures.

SIPRI data for the 2021-2025 period placed China as the world’s fifth-largest supplier, accounting for a 5.6% share of global arms exports.

During this timeframe, China’s largest customer was Pakistan with a 61% share, followed by Serbia at 6.8% and Thailand at 4.7%.

In SIPRI’s records for 2020-2024, Africa accounted for 14% of China’s major arms exports, ranking as its second-largest market behind Asia and Oceania’s 77% share.

Between 2020 and 2024, the Beijing administration carried out arms sales to a total of 44 countries worldwide.

Continue Reading

MOST READ

Turkey