Connect with us

Europe

What is the AfD to do about the EU and NATO?

Published

on

Last month, the draft manifesto of the Alternative for Germany (AfD) for the 2014 European Parliament (EP) elections was leaked to the press, unveiling one of its most prominent stances – advocating a ‘controlled disintegration of the EU’. Despite labeling the EU as ‘deeply undemocratic’ and raising doubts about the legitimacy of the EP, the AfD is actively preparing for the 2024 elections with a robust ‘eurosceptic’ list.

During the first part of the AfD congress last weekend, however, party leaders Tino Chrupalla and Alice Weidel referred to the term ‘controlled disintegration’ in the manifesto as an ‘editorial oversight’ and stated that it would be removed in the second part of the congress this weekend.

These statements created a commotion within the party. Björn Höcke, the party’s Thuringia chief and alleged member of the ‘radical’ faction, insists on retaining the statement and has even threatened a ‘revolt’ if he is not given the opportunity to speak. On the other hand, Christine Anderson, ranked fourth on the EP list and allegedly part of the ‘moderate’ wing of the party, continues to advocate for Germany’s immediate departure from the EU.

A federation of nation-states instead of the EU

“We demand a restructuring of Europe in order to use the potential of nation-states and rebuild the bridge to the east,” Chrupalla said last month.

Arguing that the European Union ‘usurps national competences without replacing the nation-state’ and that the European Commission is ‘not democratic enough’ because it ‘lacks legitimacy’, Chrupalla also cited EU sanctions against Russia as a prime example of the EU’s ‘illegitimacy’, saying they ‘do not benefit citizens’ and lead to rising inflation and stagnation.

Instead of the EU, the AfD proposes ‘a new European economic and interest-based community, a league of European nations’, the co-chairman said.

AfD’s quest for ‘Staatsvolk’

In its manifesto, the AfD explicitly rejects the idea of a ‘federal Europe’. “Such an entity has neither a Staatsvolk, which are necessary prerequisites for successful states, nor the necessary minimum cultural identity,” the AfD’s draft reads.

The emphasis on Staatsvolk is ours. In literal translation, the concept of ‘people of the state’ encompasses both all national origins of a sovereign state and another, more ‘ethnonationalist’ meaning, which emphasizes the dominant national element in a sovereign state to the exclusion of other minorities. The first meaning refers to all citizens living on the territory of a country, regardless of their ethnic origin; the second refers to an exclusionary ethnonationalism.

It is important to remember that the meaning of many words in Germany was transformed with the National Socialist government. ‘Volk’ is one of them. This word, which we can easily translate into Turkish as ‘people’, for example came to refer to the German nation bound by blood and soil in the Nazi dictionary.

There are clearly people within the AfD who can defend both meanings of Staatsvolk. The AfD’s arguments in the manifesto strongly revolve around the concepts of ‘nation’, ‘sovereignty’ and ‘identity’. The terms ‘nation’ and ‘national’ alone appear 145 times in the election program.

Is the AfD changing instead of the EU?

The AfD argues that decisions should not be made in Brussels but at the center of the nation-state. The program’s introduction talks about ‘globalist elites’ taking over the EU.

The debate around the controlled disintegration of the EU could become even more heated now that the AfD has accepted the application to join the right-wing group Identity and Democracy (ID) in the EP. The current main ID parties, the French National Union (Marine Le Pen) and the Italian Lega (Matteo Salvini), seem to have softened their positions on a federal Europe.

Marine Le Pen, for example, has abandoned her previous advocacy of dissolving the EU and is instead pushing for a ‘fundamental reform’ of the bloc. Similarly, the Lega is now gradually abandoning its ‘eurosceptic’ ideas and is trying to build a broad alliance with center-right forces for the upcoming elections.

In an interview with Deutschlandfunk at the end of last month, Harald Weye, the AfD parliamentary group’s spokesman for European policy, argued that the phrase ‘controlled disintegration of the EU’ was literally ‘one person’s grammatical carelessness’. In the elections of 2017, 2019 and 2021, the AfD openly advocated a ‘Dexit’ – Germany’s exit from the EU – as a ‘must’. The program for the 2021 Bundestag elections stated: “The transformation of the European Union into a planned economic superstate in recent years has led us to the realization that our fundamental reform approaches cannot be implemented in the EU. We consider it necessary for Germany to leave the European Union and establish a new European economic and interest community,” it said.

AfD’s plan for a ‘more German Europe’

An analysis of the Magdeburg party conference in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (faz) claims that the co-chairs have different views on the issue. According to faz, Alice Weidel sees withdrawal as absurd, but Tino Chrupalla is as sympathetic to a controlled break-up of the EU as he is to withdrawal from NATO.

According to a report in WELT, sources close to AfD leader Weidel say that the AfD is advocating a softer wording in order not to scare its partners in the ID, including its allies in the EP, the National Union and the Lega. Weidel recently told Stern, “I prefer to talk about breaking up the EU into parts, which makes sense in some parts, such as common security and defense policy. But that’s where it has failed so far,” he said.

A similar attitude can be seen in the attitude towards the eurozone. “Germany doesn’t need the euro,” the party’s 2013 Bundestag election campaign said. The following year, this position was softened and a ‘more flexible monetary order’ was proposed for the EU and ‘the stability-oriented euro countries should create a smaller monetary system among themselves on the basis of the Maastricht Treaty’.

Ten years later, the draft European Election Program for 2024 does not even mention leaving the Eurozone. It is now only about changing the Eurosystem. In fact, the AfD’s proposal to keep Germany in the eurozone and introduce a more ‘stability-oriented’ monetary system is criticized as making the EU ‘even more German than before’. The European economic area, which is very favorable for German capital, should remain with a common currency, but the costs of maintaining it should be reduced. Above all, there should be no ‘transfer payments’ to other countries at Germany’s expense.

It is important to note that the AfD is not alone. During the Greek crisis, the Free Democrats (FDP), and Frank Schäffler in particular, opposed the bailout package for Greece and financial aid for the Eurozone in general. There is no doubt that these ideas are also quite widespread within the CDU/CSU.

Germany’s withdrawal from NATO is being discussed

In addition to the EU, another topic of discussion is the US and NATO.

In the party’s European election manifesto, seven AfD state leaders, including Björn Höcke, call for ‘European states to finally take responsibility for their own security in their own hands’ and describe NATO as ‘the so-called protective umbrella of a distant hegemon’.

The Seven’s motion argues that the ‘Zeitenwende’ (turning point) that Chancellor Olaf Scholz proposed last year for the reform of the German army should mean that European states should ‘take responsibility for their own security into their own hands’ instead of seeking refuge under the ‘so-called protective umbrella of a distant and self-serving hegemon’.

The motion goes on to say that European countries have been ‘set back’ by the policies of the European Union and that “the policy of military alliance has exacerbated these developments. The EU’s Common Security and Defense Policy (CSDP) has failed to establish an independent European collective security system in the face of the US-led NATO,” the motion says.

The motion seeks to amend the preamble of the Federal Program Commission’s draft motion. The proposal states that the eastward expansion of the EU and NATO has given the US ‘even deeper influence over the European order’. The seven believe that European countries are being drawn into conflicts that are not their own and are diametrically opposed to their ‘natural interests’, such as ‘fruitful trade relations in the Eurasian region’.

But Martin Vincentz, the leader of the state of North Rhine-Westphalia, does not want the motion to be perceived as a position against NATO. “As one of the signatories, I don’t see the motion as an exit from NATO, but as a strengthening of European defense policy in the interest of NATO,” Vincentz told WELT AM SONNTAG.

It is hard to say that there is a clear consensus within the party on relations with the US and NATO. For example, a joint motion by Kurt Kleinschmidt, president of Schleswig-Holstein, and state parliamentarians from North Rhine-Westphalia and Berlin states that ‘excellent political relations require that American foreign and security policy strategies do not contradict German and European strategies’.

The group also wants to include in the European election manifesto a sentence from the basic program adopted in 2016: “NATO membership is in Germany’s foreign and security policy interests insofar as NATO limits itself to its task as a defense alliance.”

Another motion for an amendment on NATO was submitted by some state parliamentarians from Hamburg and North Rhine-Westphalia. “In view of the emerging and possibly unstoppable bloc formation between the two rivals, the United States and China, we believe that it is best for Germany to remain in the current alliance and use all possibilities to prioritize its own national interests,” the motion reads.

This includes expanding NATO’s European footprint and thus Germany’s own economic, cultural and military capabilities “in order to have a stronger influence in the world and to avoid having to obey Washington’s every whim,” according to the motion. According to the AfD, “then there would also be no need for a permanent deployment of US troops in Europe.”

The AfD’s 2017 party program ‘Manifesto for Germany’ also states that “NATO membership is in Germany’s interests in terms of foreign and security policy as long as NATO’s role remains as a defense alliance. We are in favor of a significant strengthening of the European pillar of the North Atlantic Alliance.” However, the AfD favors the withdrawal of allied troops and nuclear weapons deployed on German soil.

Europe

Poland bids for NATO nuclear programme to train F-35 fighter pilots

Published

on

Poland has applied to join the air component of NATO’s nuclear deterrence programme.

According to a report by the newspaper Gazeta Wyborcza, which cited alliance sources, Polish F-35 pilots will be trained in the use of nuclear bombs if the application is approved.

The news portal WP Wiadomości also reported that pilots of Poland’s F-35 fighter jets are planned to be trained to deploy US nuclear bombs under NATO’s Nuclear Sharing programme.

Information provided by NATO sources indicates that the Warsaw administration applied to join the Dual-Capable Aircraft (DCA) programme, which paves the way for participation in the Nuclear Sharing mechanism.

This mechanism allows NATO allies to use US tactical nuclear weapons in the event of war.

The US is said to be still assessing Poland’s application.

According to Defence24, which cited the report in question, Polish pilots and technical personnel will undergo specialised training in the US if the application is accepted.

In addition, the F-35 fighter jets will be equipped with additional hardware to carry out nuclear missions.

The training process is projected to take approximately two years.

Warsaw does not plan to station nuclear munitions on its territory

Polish Deputy Defence Minister Paweł Zalewski previously announced that there were no plans to deploy US nuclear munitions on the country’s territory.

Under the Nuclear Sharing mechanism, the US deploys its tactical nuclear weapons on the territory of European allies.

In the event of an armed conflict, participating nations can employ US nuclear bombs, but any decision to use them requires Washington’s approval.

Debate over deploying nuclear weapons in Poland has been going on for many years.

The Polish Ministry of National Defence first mentioned plans to join NATO’s Nuclear Sharing programme in 2015.

In April 2024, Polish President Andrzej Duda stated that they were prepared to host US nuclear weapons on the country’s territory.

Russia warned that potential facilities would be considered military targets

The Kremlin warned that Russia would take countermeasures to ensure its own security if such a step were taken.

Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova argued that the facilities in question would become military targets in the event of a direct conflict with NATO.

Zakharova said: “One does not need to be a military strategist to understand that such facilities would represent a source of direct threat and naturally would inevitably enter the list of legitimate targets defined in a scenario of direct military conflict between our country and NATO.”

Speaking in August this year, Polish Deputy Defence Minister Zalewski clarified that Warsaw was interested in participating in NATO’s nuclear deterrence activities, but was not considering the deployment of nuclear warheads on its territory.

In October, Polish Defence Minister Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz confirmed his country’s desire to take part in the US nuclear deterrence programme and simultaneously develop cooperation with France in this area.

Without providing a timetable for when concrete decisions would be taken, Kosiniak-Kamysz noted that an agreement with allies had to be reached first.

Continue Reading

Europe

EU links UK energy market access to cohesion budget contributions

Published

on

The EU is looking to Britain to help plug its budget shortfall, offering access to its energy market in return.

British Prime Minister Andy Burnham is currently seeking to negotiate reintegration in a bid to lower electricity costs and demonstrate to voters the benefits of his post-Brexit policy of reconnecting with Europe.

Liberal Member of the European Parliament Sandro Gozi, who is closely involved in the negotiations, says that in exchange for this access, Britain must contribute to the EU cohesion fund, which currently sits at the centre of a political battle over the bloc’s next budget.

“Any agreement on the UK’s participation in the European electricity market must be accompanied by a financial contribution by the UK to cohesion policy,” said Gozi, who chairs the European Parliament’s delegation to the EU-UK Parliamentary Partnership Assembly.

British households pay the highest retail electricity bills among the G7 club of advanced economies, with kilowatt-hour prices running roughly five pence (0.06 euros) above average.

London wants to reconnect to the European electricity market by 2028 to gain access to cheap French nuclear power.

Burnham will visit Brussels on 20 November for an EU-UK summit, hoping to achieve tangible progress.

The EU’s 27 member states are currently locked in an impasse over the proposed 2 trillion euro EU budget for the 2028-2034 period.

Countries led by Germany want spending cuts in an ongoing political battle with Italy and other nations that receive billions of euros from cohesion funds aimed at Europe’s poorest regions.

The Italian lawmaker told Rapporteur that MEPs would formally raise the demand on Tuesday for British funding to be channelled to Europe’s poorer regions in return for energy market access.

The push for contributions to the cohesion fund, which accounts for around a third of the bloc’s current seven-year budget at 392 billion euros, follows a similar appeal from the leaders of the Netherlands, Germany, Denmark, Luxembourg, and Belgium.

In a letter dated 6 November, the group stated that London should make an “appropriate financial contribution” in exchange for energy market access.

Lucy Rigby, the Labour government’s economic secretary, acknowledged last week that discussions regarding “the mechanism for the UK’s financial contribution” had already begun.

Continue Reading

Europe

Five EU nations announce plan to deport migrants to Rwanda hub

Published

on

Five EU countries are set to open a migrant deportation centre in Rwanda next year as part of a broader drive to increase expulsions.

In statements released by the Dutch and Danish governments, it was announced that Germany, Denmark, Austria, Greece, and the Netherlands are expected to open a “return hub” ready to accept transfers in 2027.

The countries said the scheme will apply to migrants residing “illegally” within their borders who are subject to deportation orders.

The Dutch government added that it would provide an alternative if deportees cannot be returned to their countries of origin.

Deportees will either be able to integrate into Rwandan society or return to their native countries.

The plan will apply to individuals who have exhausted all legal avenues to remain in the five countries. This differs from the scrapped British agreement, which envisaged sending people to Rwanda to have their asylum claims processed.

Due to legal obstacles, the UK arrangement never took effect and was ultimately shelved by the Labour government that assumed office in 2024.

Downing Street has not ruled out the possibility of the UK joining the scheme, stating that it will monitor developments “with interest”.

According to AFP, Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez said the plan to open a facility in Rwanda has “neither a future nor a humanitarian dimension”.

“I see in this neither a future nor a humanitarian dimension. This is not a solution,” Sánchez told Spanish broadcaster Telecinco, as quoted by AFP.

While the five nations argue that the initiative to send migrants abroad complies with EU and international law, human rights organisations warn that it could violate migrant rights.

The agreement follows a recent EU reform permitting the establishment of offshore centres outside the bloc.

Speaking at a joint press conference in Vienna on Monday, Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker said the five nations want to relieve pressure on European asylum systems and deter human traffickers from organising lethal journeys across the Mediterranean.

In a written statement, the Dutch government noted that under the first phase of the agreement, the five countries “will only send back single men”, adding that the Netherlands’ focus will be on “individuals from countries of origin in the same region as Rwanda”.

Upon arrival in Rwanda, these individuals will be permitted to integrate into society, meaning they will receive residency rights and gain access to education, healthcare services, the labour market, and the legal system.

Rwandan Minister of Interior Vincent Biruta said the country is committed to cooperating with European partners to deliver a “safe, lawful, and dignified solution for migrants”.

The minister added that they will also work to “rectify the global imbalance in economic opportunities”, which he described as the “primary driver of irregular migration”.

Prior to the announcement, diplomatic sources told AFP that the centre is initially expected to run as a pilot project housing around 100 people, with each of the five countries likely sending roughly 20 migrants.

The United Nations International Organization for Migration (IOM) may assume a supporting role throughout the process.

“IOM has a long-standing history of providing assistance to migrants in transit, including under complex conditions,” an IOM spokesperson said, adding that the organisation is in talks with certain EU states regarding “plans for the establishment of return hubs or similar mechanisms”.

With elections looming in several EU member states, governments face intense pressure to demonstrate control over migration.

Clementine de Montjoye, senior Africa researcher at Human Rights Watch, stated that the choice of Rwanda is a cause for concern, citing the country’s “entrenched track record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detention, and ill-treatment in custody”, alongside its backing of armed rebels in the neighbouring Democratic Republic of the Congo:

“Paying Kigali to run a deportation programme will not only cause pain and harm to those deported, but it will also provide funding and political leverage to a government responsible for grave human rights violations at home and abroad.”

The independent EU Fundamental Rights Agency maintained that any third country hosting a return hub must “respect fundamental rights”, which includes ensuring individuals are not sent to a territory where they face a grave risk of persecution.

The agency added that unaccompanied minors must not be sent to the return centre, a condition the Dutch government confirmed will be observed.

According to the European Border and Coast Guard Agency, approximately 110,000 irregular border crossings into the EU were recorded in the first 10 months of 2026, marking a 29% decline compared with the previous year.

Roughly 18,100 crossings were detected in October; although this figure is about 6% lower than in October 2025, it represents a 22% increase over September, which was reportedly driven “largely by a sharp surge in arrivals along the Western African route to the Canary Islands”.

Continue Reading

MOST READ

Turkey